Contest Judge

4-H Contest Judge

 4-H offers many competitive events throughout the year and lots of judges are needed to share their positive comments and expertise. Judges are needed who are knowledgeable about the project being judged and who are capable of providing age-appropriate suggestions for improvement.  Some of the many competitive areas where we need judges include:

  • sewing
  • talent
  • gardening
  • foods/nutrition
  • arts and crafts
  • photography
  • computer technology
  • portfolios
  • robotics
  • GPS

Advance preparation

 

Contest guidelines and score sheets are available in advance to the contestants and judges. Judges should review the specific contest guidelines and score sheet criteria to understand what to expect and to make the judging process easier and more efficient.

                   

During the Contest

 

All 4-H Contests begin with Danish System Judging. In Danish System Judging, the contestants are evaluated based on their individual competency in the project area, within their age division, and according to the specific contest guidelines. The contestants are not judged against each other; consequently, there is no limit to the number of blue ribbons the judges may award. The judges, usually two or three, independently score each contestant’s project, and the scores averaged to determine the final percentage of each contestant. The ribbons are awarded as follows:

 

Blue Ribbon (excellent) = 90-100%

Red Ribbon (good) = 75-89%

White (fair) = 74% & below

 

The judge’s evaluation is recorded on a score sheet that lists the criteria and points available. The most important part of the evaluation is written comments.  A score sheet with a balance of positive comments and suggestions for improvement provides the contestant with constructive feedback.

 

The ultimate goal is for the children to walk away feeling positive about their contest experience. A positive experience helps them have a desire to learn and participate in future events. 

 

Once the Danish ribbons are determined, the three highest scores in each grade division receive special awards. If a tie exists, the judges break the tie. Consequently, judges need to stay until all scores and awards have been determined.

Time Commitment: Generally, two to three hours depending on the contest and the number of participants.